Not All Leads Are Equal. Most Salespeople Have No Idea.

I said to a client last week that their reps had no appreciation for the steady flow of leads landing on their desk every single week. In one department I have worked, we made fourteen thousand hard cold calls to get one sale. Fourteen thousand. When an inbound lead came in we treated it like gold. We practically held a ceremony.

That is the gap I keep seeing. Businesses investing heavily in generating warm, signal-qualified leads and handing them to reps who treat them like just another name on a list. The lead quality is already doing ninety-five percent of the work and the rep still manages to drop it.

The difference is not the rep’s skill. It is that they have never had to make fourteen thousand cold calls for one sale. They do not know what a real lead costs.


Leads Are Not Equal and Most Businesses Treat Them Like They Are

There is a spectrum of lead quality that runs from a cold scraped email address at one end to a prospect who has already identified their problem, done their research, and is actively looking for a solution at the other. The distance between those two things is enormous, and yet most businesses manage them with the same process, the same script, and the same follow-up sequence.

A cold list is not prospecting. It is gambling. You are betting that somewhere in a database of names, a small percentage happen to have a problem you solve, happen to be in a buying cycle right now, and happen to be receptive to being contacted by a stranger. The hit rate reflects that. It is low because the premise is low.

A signal-qualified lead is something completely different. It is a business that has already told you, through its behaviour, that it has the problem you solve. Not explicitly. Not in a form submission. But through the signals it is putting out into the market every day for anyone paying close enough attention to read.

That is the difference between cold outreach and signal-based prospecting. One is volume dressed up as strategy. The other is intelligence dressed up as a phone call.


What a Signal Actually Looks Like

I rang the main switchboard of the Australilan Signals Directorate. (Australia’s spy agency) Gave my name as Trooper May, my ID number, said I was looking for the team responsible for the data centre move. 

“We will be in touch.” Click. 

One minute later my phone rang. One question. “Trooper May how did you identify that we were moving our data centre?” Then silence. 

I explained the process. I booked the meeting. 

A Google Alert landed in my inbox. Not much of a lead to most. A bob ad that said something like. ‘Government department. Project Manager, Data Centre’. 

I pulled the thread. 

Worked out the department was the Signals Directorate. Kept digging and pieced together they were sitting in a colocation facility that had recently been acquired by a Chinese company. That is not a commercial inconvenience for a signals intelligence operation. That is a potential national security breach. 

There was no tender on the market. No form submission. No inbound enquiry. But the signal was sitting there in plain sight for anyone who knew what they were looking at. A security implication that connected two publicly available facts into a commercial opportunity. That is a signal-qualified lead. By the time I made the call, ninety-five percent of the sales work was already done. 


Trigger Events Versus Behaviour Signals

There are two types of signals worth understanding because they require different responses. 

A trigger event is discrete, time-bound, and predictable. The cleaning company contract that renews in two years. You know exactly when the buying window opens. Nothing in between matters. You wait for it, you prepare for it, and you show up at exactly the right moment with the right conversation. That is not cold outreach. That is a warm call with perfect timing. 

A behaviour signal is subtler and requires interpretation. Example 1. A company getting hacked is a signal for cybersecurity companies, risk management firms, their competitors, and every adjacent industry that touches that risk category.  

Example 2. A company moving office is a signal for painters, fit out companies, tech companies, office furniture companies.  

Example 3. A company hiring 50 new on the road sales reps, is a signal to car dealerships, laptop and mobile phone companies.  

These are not guesses. They are patterns and correlations. And patterns are readable if you are paying attention. 


Where the Signals Live

The companies that genuinely need what you offer are not posting about it. They are feeling it quietly. Deals slipping. Acquisitions and mergers. New divisions stalling. Revenue plateauing while costs keep climbing. The invisible cracks in an operation that spell opportunity for a salesperson who is looking at the right things.

Seek ads are an indication they need recruitment services.  

Bad reviews on Google, Reddit, Glassdoor, and industry platforms tell you about culture, product gaps, and customer experience failures. A cluster of negative staff reviews about direction and leadership often precedes a restructure. A run of customer complaints about delivery is a signal for anyone selling into that gap. 

Shareholder reports, ASX announcements, up and down P&Ls, disparity between revenue and sales spend, high income with minimal staff, large recruitment spend relative to revenue, high tender costs compared to closed business. All of these tell a story about where the pain is sitting. All of them are publicly available.

PR and media releases tell you about expansions, acquisitions, new offices, APAC moves, and new verticals. Every one of those events creates operational needs that did not exist the week before the announcement. The salesperson who reads the release the morning it drops and calls that afternoon is six weeks ahead of everyone else.

Google Alerts cost nothing. Set them on target company names, key personnel, competitor names, and industry terms. Let the intelligence come to you passively. The Google Alert that led me to the Signals Directorate had been running for months before that job ad appeared.

Partner tip-offs are the most valuable signals because they arrive with context already attached. Identify who else is interested in the same triggers you are, the adjacent service providers, the complementary businesses, the industry connectors, and build deliberate intelligence-sharing relationships around that shared interest. A partner who flags a struggling business they just encountered is not giving you a lead. They are giving you a qualified opportunity with timing attached.


The Rep Who Does Not Know What a Lead Costs

We don’t do lead generation, because handing good leads to people who have never had to earn them is crushing.

When you do not know what a cold call campaign actually costs, when you have never sat in a room and made fourteen thousand calls to get one sale, you cannot feel the value of a warm lead. It lands in your inbox and it looks like more work. You follow up once. Maybe twice. You move on. You have no frame of reference for what it cost to get that person to the point of interest and no appreciation for what walking away from it actually means.

This is one of the most expensive and least visible problems in sales operations. The marketing function or the prospecting function generates quality signal-based leads and hands them to a sales team that treats them like cold outreach. The conversion rate reflects the effort, not the quality of the lead, and everyone blames the wrong variable.

The fix is not always a better lead. Sometimes it is making sure the people receiving the leads understand exactly what it took to generate them and what it means commercially to let one go cold.


The Real Point

Most prospecting is hope. It is volume dressed up as strategy, scraping emails and blasting messages and waiting for the small percentage who happen to be in the right place at the right time to respond. Signal-based prospecting is the opposite. It is reading the room before the deal exists, identifying the businesses that are already feeling the problem you solve, and being there to tell them about the pain they haven’t even identified yet.

The difference in conversion rate between those two approaches is not incremental. It is the difference between fourteen thousand calls for one sale and a rep who treats an inbound lead like gold because they know exactly what it took to get there.


Similar Posts